Thursday, September 24, 2009

a psychological debate

Brady: Although this part of the science of psychology is fascinating I don't especially enjoy applying the information to my own life. I like to think of my reactions/thoughts/perception of the world to be a mystifying expression of my inner being. When I read about Acetylocholine, GABA, Norepinephrine, Dopamine, Serotonin, etc, as mere chemicals dictating my fortunate soul's existence, releasing and antagonizing emotions based on the world's stimuli; my personal worth decreases dramatically. Chemicals affecting my conscience quantifies and utilitarian-izes emotions. My sadness, or happiness is not the traveling of molecular formulas to certain parts of my brain. Sadness and happiness have essences unexplainable in the abstract world every individual is a part of.

Ronson: Although this part of the science of psychology is fascinating I don't especially enjoy applying the information to my own life. I like to think of my reactions/thoughts/perception of the world to be a mystifying expression of my inner being.

I don't understand why you think that these are mutually exclusive? Can the science and the mysticism both coexist in the same space? Science cannot fully explain how these chemicals work when we are sad or happy - science can theorize, but nothing has been made fact. So, within the gaps that science leaves is the cozy room where the mystical can live and breath - growing and giving life to your depreciated soul.

Brady: Science has a way of progressing theories into axioms. A long time ago it was generally accepted by mankind that the earth was the center of the universe (an ethnocentric civilization naturally considers themselves geocentric). Yet as science prospered Galileo proved that the earth was not the center of the universe. Science has created a trajectory soaring higher than mankind itself, where exactly is the end to science's discovery? Entangled in this hot pursuit mankind may one day collectively believe their bodies' interactions with the world are made up of sheer processes, chemical and artificial actions. This may sound radical when placed in the modern context, but time has proved to change the world's thinking before and I guarantee it will occur again.

Prabhdeep: i read your statement several times and tried to understand your point of view more thoroughly and this is what i interpreted. Im sorry if i am incorrect please correct me. So what your saying is that our emotions and the chemical changes that occur in our bodies are not because of what science has discovered, but is
"our unexplainable inner being?"

Brady: That's the best way that I can explain my opinion. I don't know for sure. "Unexplainable inner being," has more implications and contingencies than I would like to settle on; there is an objectivity out there somewhere.